PreviewYou're previewing CFO AI Ledger. Sign in to use it.Sign in
← All lessons
L2 · Proving value: business cases, ROI and value tracking9 min read

The anatomy of an AI business case

An AI business case is an ordinary investment case with four extra traps: benefits depend on adoption, costs include usage-based lines, time saved is not automatically cash, and the technology and prices change during the project.

The six parts

  1. The problem and the metric: what process, what volume, what baseline (time, cost, errors, cash, accuracy).
  2. The benefit model: volume × time saved × loaded cost, plus other benefits (errors avoided, early-payment discounts, fraud prevented, working capital). State how each becomes cash or capacity.
  3. Costs, in three groups:
  4. one-off: build, integration, data clean-up, change and training
  5. run: licences or seats, tokens or usage, people to supervise and maintain
  6. hidden: security reviews, audit work, model updates, vendor management
  7. Adoption: a curve by year or a ramp in months. Benefits arrive only as people actually use the tool.
  8. Risk: a haircut on benefits for delivery risk, and a sensitivity on the drivers that matter.
  9. Decision and tracking plan: hurdle rate, payback, kill criteria, and how value will be reported after go-live.

Common errors

  • Counting 100% adoption from month one.
  • Treating every hour saved as cash.
  • Leaving out run costs that scale with usage.
  • No baseline, so value can never be proven.
  • No end date or kill criteria for the pilot.

Use the ROI builder

The hub's ROI & business case builder turns these inputs into yearly cash flows, NPV, IRR, payback, a sensitivity tornado and break-even adoption, and exports a one-page case for your investment committee.

What this means for the CFO

Hold AI to the same investment discipline as everything else, with two extra demands: an adoption curve and a realization plan for time saved.

When a case reaches you, ask three questions: What adoption does it assume, and what happens to NPV at half that? Which run costs grow with usage? How exactly does saved time become cash or capacity, and who owns that? A case that answers all three is worth funding; one that doesn't should go back.

Use the ROI builder's export as the standard format for your investment committee.

Diagram

The anatomy of an AI business case

Real example

At JPMorgan Chase, President Daniel Pinto said in September 2024 that the bank was rolling out its LLM Suite assistant to 140,000 employees and raised his estimate of the value of its AI use cases from up to $1.5 billion (May 2024) to "closer to $2 billion", adding that "a lot of that is related to prevention of fraud" — an example of a value estimate that names where the benefit comes from. Source: Banking Dive — JPMorgan Chase rolls out LLM Suite generative AI tool to 140,000 employees (Sep 12, 2024) ↗

Use it

Quick check · 3 questions

  1. 1.Which assumption most often inflates AI business cases?

  2. 2.Which cost line is most likely to grow with usage?

  3. 3.What must a case say about hours saved?

0 of 3 answered

Sources

Last reviewed 2026-10-01.